Find Your Sweet Spot

Stoltzfus Bakery

Local Favorite

4.4

New Castle, DE

$

🏆 Highly recommended on Reddit r/Delaware

About

An Amish bakery inside the New Castle Farmers Market offering fresh homemade baked goods straight from Lancaster County tradition. Stoltzfus is consistently recommended by Delaware locals as having superior donuts to nearby competitors — their Amish-style yeast donuts are soft, pillowy, and made with time-honored recipes. Beyond donuts, customers rave about their butter pound cakes, homemade dinner rolls, pies, and whoopie pies. A true taste of Pennsylvania Dutch country baking without the drive to Lancaster.

Specialties

Amish-style yeast donutsFresh butter pound cakesHomemade dinner rollsPiesWhoopie piesFresh baked breads from Lancaster County

Features

Amish bakeryLancaster County recipesfresh baked dailyinside farmer's markettraditional techniques

Only open Thu-Sun during farmer's market hours. Many locals prefer Stoltzfus over the nearby Dutch Country Donuts — try both and decide for yourself.

Social Media

📸Instagram 👥Facebook

Is this your business?

Claim this listing to update your information, get a verified badge, and receive a free backlink badge.

Claim This Listing

Contact Info

110 N Dupont Highway, New Castle, DE 19720

www.newcastlefarmersmarket.com/store-directory/full-list/stoltzfus-bakery

Thu: 9am-3pm, Fri: 9am-8pm, Sat: 9am-8pm, Sun: 10am-5pm

Details

Price Range$

Established2005

DeliveryNo - in-store only

ParkingFree parking lot at farmer's market

AccessibilityYes

Embed a badge on your site

Other Donut Shops in New Castle

Dutch Country Donuts

Chocolate frosted donuts (signature)Peanut butter and jelly filled