Best Donuts in New Jersey (2026 Guide)
New Jersey punches way above its weight in donuts, with an incredible density of quality shops from the Shore to the suburbs. The Garden State's diverse communities fuel an impressive range from classic crullers to innovative artisan creations.
Top 15 Donut Shops in New Jersey
Why it's notable: The top-rated donut shop in New Jersey, known for Johnny Tsunami (donut + ice cream + hot fudge), Salty Dog (maple, pork roll, salted caramel), Captain's French Toast, with 1 award, serving since 2018, featuring made-to-order and nautical theme.
Why it's notable: One of New Jersey's highest-rated shops, known for S'mores donut, Pretzel-crusted fried chicken with pepper caramel, Doughnut bread pudding, serving since 2015, featuring Artisanal creations and Frozen custard.
Why it's notable: One of New Jersey's highest-rated shops, known for Samoa, Caramel Apple Pie, Dream Cream, with 3 awards, serving since 2017, featuring made-to-order and monthly rotating menu.
Why it's notable: A standout Oakhurst favorite, known for FUNfetti Triple Laya, Jersey Shore themed donuts (Belmar Bliss, Route 35, The Freehold), Weekend specials (15+ options), with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring Made to order and Vegan options.
Why it's notable: A standout Freehold favorite, known for FUNfetti Triple Laya, Jersey Shore themed donuts (Belmar Bliss, Route 35, The Freehold), Weekend specials (15+ options), with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring Made to order and Vegan options.
Why it's notable: A standout Toms River favorite, known for PB&J Donut, French Toast Donut, Twix Donut, with 2 awards, serving since 2019, featuring walk-up window and made-to-order.
Why it's notable: A standout Manville favorite, known for Fresh donuts, Italian pastries, Custom cakes, serving since 1985, featuring Full bakery and Italian pastries.
Why it's notable: A standout Asbury Park favorite, known for Salty Dog (caramel drizzle, dulce de leche, sea salt), Wake 'n' Bacon (maple glaze, bacon bits), Music Donut of the Week, with 1 award, serving since 2015, featuring Vegan options and Gluten-free available.
Why it's notable: A standout New Milford favorite, known for NJ Cheesecake Donut (cream cheese filling, Belgian chocolate shavings), Italian Rainbow Cookie Donut (weekends only), Small batch throughout the day, with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring No preservatives or HFCS and Small batch fresh.
Why it's notable: A standout Fort Lee favorite, known for NJ Cheesecake Donut (cream cheese filling, Belgian chocolate shavings), Italian Rainbow Cookie Donut (weekends only), Small batch throughout the day, with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring No preservatives or HFCS and Small batch fresh.
Why it's notable: A standout West Caldwell favorite, known for NJ Cheesecake Donut (cream cheese filling, Belgian chocolate shavings), Italian Rainbow Cookie Donut (weekends only), Small batch throughout the day, with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring No preservatives or HFCS and Small batch fresh.
Why it's notable: A standout Nutley favorite, known for NJ Cheesecake Donut (cream cheese filling, Belgian chocolate shavings), Italian Rainbow Cookie Donut (weekends only), Small batch throughout the day, with 3 awards, serving since 2015, featuring No preservatives or HFCS and Small batch fresh.
Why it's notable: A standout Montclair favorite, known for Brioche doughnuts, Apple cider glazed with fresh apples and crumble, Maple bacon, with 3 awards, serving since 2012, featuring Brioche-based donuts and Giant donut cakes for occasions.
Why it's notable: A standout Northvale favorite, known for Apple cider donuts, Small batch throughout the day, Tree-nut and peanut free, with 3 awards, serving since 2017, featuring Nut-free facility and Small batch fresh.
Why it's notable: A standout Mullica Hill favorite, known for HUGE brioche donuts (requires two hands), Salted Caramel Pretzel, Candied Bacon Donut, with 2 awards, serving since 2021, featuring full restaurant and full bar.
Donut Shops by City in New Jersey
Explore Nearby States
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best donut shop in New Jersey?
Nauti Donuts in Ocean City is the top-rated donut shop in New Jersey with a 4.9 rating.
How many donut shops are in New Jersey?
We have 53 donut shops listed across 41 cities in New Jersey on NearbyDonuts.com.
Which cities in New Jersey have the best donuts?
The top cities for donuts in New Jersey include Freehold (3 shops), Montclair (3 shops), Ocean City (3 shops), Fort Lee (2 shops), Mullica Hill (2 shops).