Der Dutchman Restaurant
Local Favorite4.3
Sarasota, FL
$🏆 Pages of Travel Best Donuts Sarasota🏆 Amish restaurant institution
About
Der Dutchman is an Amish restaurant institution in Sarasota known for its expansive breakfast buffet, but the donuts deserve their own spotlight. Their orange cake donuts — when available — are a revelation, with options for regular glazed or orange frosted varieties. The Long Johns are among the best in Sarasota, and all baked goods benefit from the Amish tradition of using real butter and quality ingredients. The restaurant also offers pies, bread, and full meal service, making it a complete dining destination.
Specialties
Orange Cake donuts (seasonal)Orange Frosted donutsLong JohnsClassic GlazedAmish-style baked goods
Features
Amish-stylefull restaurantbreakfast buffetpies and breadseasonal specials
The orange cake donuts are seasonal — ask if they're available.
Social Media
Is this your business?
Claim this listing to update your information, get a verified badge, and receive a free backlink badge.
Claim This ListingContact Info
3713 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL 34232
Mon-Sat: 7am-8pm. Closed Sun
Details
Price Range$
Established1978
DeliveryNo
ParkingLarge free parking lot
AccessibilityYes
Embed a badge on your site
Get Your BadgeOther Donut Shops in Sarasota
Five-O Donut Co
4.5
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup donutCookie Monster donut
Peachey's Baking Co
4.7
Amish-style sourdough vanilla glazed doughnutsSoft pretzels
Mochinut Sarasota
4.4
Mochi donuts (rice flour)Matcha flavor
Jack's Donuts of Florida
4.4
Bavarian Cream with chocolate ganacheLemon filled
Meaney's Mini Donuts
4.5
Mini donuts (beignet-style)Powdered sugar minis
Gold Star Donuts
4.3
Old Fashioned/CrullersPowdered Sugar Cake donuts